Payment Options

Agency Benefits

About NMIC

Contact Us

Useful Links


Payment Options


To avoid a late fee or cancellation, payment must be submitted on or before the stated due date.

Credit Card

We accept Visa, MasterCard, or Discover.

Electronic Check (E-check)

You may have your balance due directly deducted from your checking or savings account. 

How to make a one-time payment

To make a one-time credit card or electronic check payment:

  • Call your agency or company and provide the information over the telephone.

  • Go to the consumer log in and select "Make a payment."

This is a non-recurring transaction and will have to be repeated to pay any future outstanding balance due. If you have more than one policy with Northern Mutual you will have to submit separate payments for each policy, (i.e. auto and home policy).

Electronic Funds Transfers (EFT)

This option will automatically pull your payment from your checking or savings account on a recurring basis. This will eliminate any service fees and you will have no interruption in coverage. If you would like to set up automated EFT withdrawals for future payment, please contact your agent.






201 Quincy Street
P.O. Box 570
Hancock, MI 49930

(906) 482-2880 Tel
(906) 482-7659 Fax

Toll-Free Phone Numbers
(877) 437-5925 Nationwide


Hours: Monday – Friday 8:00-4:30 EST

Our current A.M. Best rating is "A-, Excellent".


© 2024 Northern Mutual Insurance Company. All rights reserved.

Website development: Opusweb